Winners

Season 1 (3rd Life)
After 8 episodes of 3rd Life, and 12 members losing their final life, Grian beat GoodTimesWithScar in a final fist fight to the death on top of Pizza's grave.

Season 2 (Last Life)
In the final ninth episode of Last Life, when there were only four of the seventeen members left on the server, a final fight was initiated. Rendog killed PearlescentMoon, Smajor1995 killed InTheLittleWoods, and finally Smajor1995 killed Rendog, with the assistance of a zombie.